Jason david beduhn the myth of marcion as redactor. About the middle of the second century 140155 he traveled to rome, where he joined the syrian gnostic cerdo. Marcion denied the resurrection of the body because flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of god 1 cor. However a number of the phrases in it have survived, in the form of the testimony of terullian in adversus marcionem c. Sep 17, 2019 harnack presents marcions historical significance. Marcion s main contention was that the god from the old testament was a god of vengeance, jealousy, and wrath, whereas jesus. Detailed arguments for or against marcion being the author of the differences from luke, or whether the differences actually existed in mcg, are given in the following pages, illustrated by using quotes from tertullians adv. Christianity is that marcions undisputed talent for communal organization urged the rest of the christians to improve their. This insight casts a new light on marcion s place within the history of the church, as the initiator of a fundamental crisis of the old testament in the second century. Although marcion is focused on to study the gnosticism and the early christianity, it is a customizable universal library working with various file formats html, pdf, djvu and allowing to collect, organize and backup books and texts of any kind and search for words and phrases in a desired selection of texts.
Marcion s pre144 manuscript of paul what i shall call the premar cionite text of rome must have contained a number of marginal glosses, for one of them is signaled by tertullian, when discussing pauls interpreta tion gal. Content management system cms task management project portfolio management time tracking pdf. Marcions gospel, compared verse by verse with luke tricky. There needed to be a distance between god and matter in marcion s thinking, so the creator god of the old testament was not a true god or he was a lesser god. Marcionism was an early christian dualist belief system that originated in the teachings of marcion of sinope in rome around the year 144 marcion was the son of a bishop of sinope in pontus. Unfortunately or perhaps fortunately, there are no known copies of antithesis in existence. Pdf this article highlights the importance of reconsidering the influence of the.
Among these is the fact that polycarp does not bother to name his enemy, and we still do not have the necessary irrefutable evidence to do it for him. The entirety of the gospel is divided into 6 sections. Concerning the reconstruction of the first verse of the marcionite corpus paulinum, vigiliae christianae 42 1988. Marcion s primary antithesis involved faith and law. Marcion is a software forming a study environment of ancient languages esp. Although marcion is focused on to study the gnosticism and early christianity, it is an universal library working with various file formats and allowing to collect, organize. In addition, the text has been hyperlinked to two of the major hostile witnesses utilized for its reconstruction, tertullians against marcion adversus marcionem, book iv, and ephiphanius panarion sect.
Marcion refused pointblank to allegorise the ot text37 instead he rejected it completely. We see this rejection most clearly in his work, antithesis, where he pits the new testament against the old testament. Higgins, the latin text in marcion and tertullian, vigchr 5 1951, 142, and t. Oct 28, 20 marcion holds a lasting legacy for christians as the inventor of the new testament. Media in category marcion the following 7 files are in this category, out of 7 total. Part of a library of materials dealing with gnosis and gnosticism, both ancient and modern. Marcion and the roman church was the antithesis between. Marcion s major work was entitled antithesis and has not survived.
Marcion does not understand the old testament in the light of the new, he interprets the new testament in the light of the old. Marcion had bought into platos idea that matter is bad, and so, the god of the old testament, the god who created the world, was not a god that he could stomach. Marcion article about marcion by the free dictionary. Marcion also rejected the real incarnation of christ, claiming that he was a manifestation of the father. The gospel of marcion, called by its adherents the gospel of the lord, was a text used by the mid2nd century christian teacher marcion of sinope to the exclusion of the other gospels.
He understood paul to have rejected the old testament and its god by saying the reading of the old testament and moses. That prelate had stultified himself and broken faith with tertullian. Marcion s teaching was condemned as heresy in the year 144. Neoplatonism and gnosticism western esotericism perennial philosophy esoteric christianity theosophy carl jung gnosticism in modern times v t e. Marcion taught that the god of the old testament was not the true god but rather that the true and higher god had been revealed only with jesus christ. May 02, 20 the problem with marcion is in my view that he was a literalist, which is why i prefer the valentinian mythicism.
The reception of the canon by the modern church is inhibited, it seems to me, by functional marcionism. Aug 05, 2005 i am an admirer of marcion as well as arius. The churchs scripture and functional marcionism daniel l. His theology rejected the deity described in the hebrew scriptures and in distinction affirmed the father of christ as the true god. The first appearance of the collected set of genuine letters of paul was in marcion s gnostic bible, in ad. He believed paul had shown this antithesis the opposites of jehovahs law and the grace of god the father. I have not found many books about him, especially no primary, original sources. Thus to say that marcion was faced with an authoritative canon of four gospels, selected from one of the four, excised large chunks of material from it, and elevated it to a level above the others, in full consciousness of having chosen a practice opposed to the worldwide church, is. The epistle of the apostle paul to the laodiceans pdf. What we know about marcions teachings comes mainly from the. Marcions theological errors and there were many came from one main root. We dont have a copy, but so many early christian writers quoted it, that they have reproduced the whole thing. Pdf israel in marcions theology and the challenge of. Marcion s main contention was that the god from the old testament was a god of vengeance, jealousy, and wrath, whereas jesus from the new testament was kind, merciful, and loving.
He believed paul had shown this antithesis the opposites of. This is not due to an intentional cleansing or burning by orthodox christians. Marcions primary antithesis involved faith and law. Contradictions between the old testament diety and the new testament god. A note those who identify marcion as the false teacher against whom polycarp writes in his letter to the philippians continue to face difficult problems. The reception of the canon by the modern church is inhibited, it. Apostle john and marcion of sinope, from jpm library ms 748, 11th c. In marcions book known as the antitheses, which exists only in fragments quoted by others, we find endorsement of everything pauline, including faith alone. In the fifteenth year of the reign of tiberius caesar, 2. Marcion, the son of the bishop of sinope a seaport of pontus along the black sea who had become a wealthy shipowner, stood before the presbyters to expound his teachings in order to win others to his point of. The difference between the two christs, is that the jewish christ was ordained by the creator for the restoration of the people alone from its dispersion, while our christ was appointed by the supremely good god for the liberation of the whole human race. Marcion s use of the christian canon brings him closer to the scriptureoriented christianity of the great councils than it does to the mythoriented gnostics.
I recommend it for anyone who is put off by yahweh as much as i am. Imposing latesecondcentury mores on an earlysecondcentury figure leads to great misunderstanding. About the middle of the second century 140155 he traveled to rome, where he joined the syrian gnostic cerdo marcion believed that jesus was the savior sent by god, and paul the apostle was his. Marcion, the canon, the law, and the historical jesus. He considered the creator god the inferior of the two. The antithesis of marcion on early christian writings. The problem with marcion is in my view that he was a literalist, which is why i prefer the valentinian mythicism. Text and transmission from marcion to augustine, studies in judaism in late antiquity 121 1975. Marcion, the son of the bishop of sinope a seaport of pontus along the black sea who had become a wealthy shipowner, stood before the presbyters to expound his teachings in order to win others to his point of view. He understood how paul had reprimanded the church at galatia for much the same thing. Marcion and the roman church was the antithesis between jehovah and the heavenly father. Marcion of sinope edinburgh research explorer the university. The development of the canon of the new testament marcion.
Marcion sponsored an open christianity that met in churches. Gard the scriptures are collected in what is known as the it canon, that is, a grouping of writings received as authoritative and normative for faith and life. Marcion and the marcionites 144 3rd century ce at the end of july, 144 ce, a hearing took place before the clergy of the christian congregations in rome. Marcion taught that there were two gods, proclaiming that the stern, lawgiving, creator god of the old testament, and the good, merciful god of the new testament were different. The writings of religious groups that became extinct were largely doomed to extinction themselves because writing materials of that time simply did not. Marcion affirmed jesus christ as the savior sent by god and paul as his chief apostle, but he rejected the hebrew bible and yahweh. Marcionism, similar to gnosticism, depicted the god of the old testament as a tyrant or demiurge see also god as the devil.
Antithesis, marcion attempted to expose the seemingly irresolvable conflicting natures of the supposedly unloving and inferior god of the old testament books versus the loving and superior god of the new testament books. Marcions scriptural canon, argues that marcion not only put together the very first christian canon of scriptures, he gave christianity very idea of doing so. Marcion preached that the god who sent jesus into the world was a different, higher deity than the creator god of judaism. The gnostic affinity or group identity was a secret bond that. The antithesis radical rejection of judaism and all jewish scripture founded churches and taught people. Marcion and getting unhitched from the old testament. One way to handle this charge is to read it as a metaphor for despoiling the spotless virginal bride of christ the church. Marcion, an avid disciple of paul, appeared on the seen determined to rescue the church from its judaic beliefs.
The following is a link to a hypothetical reconstruction of his antithesis which is no longer extant. The forums in the christian congregations category are now open only to christian members. Marcion, the canon, the law, and the historical jesus a survey of marcion s life and legacy. He denied that christ was truly incarnate because flesh, like. On the other hand, there was the faith alone doctrine of paul.
Contains many coptic texts, grammars, greek texts, liddelscott greekenglish lexicon, and others. Coptic, greek, latin and providing many tools and resources dictionaties, grammars, texts. Marcion, book iv, epiphanius panarion 42, and other sources as necessary see tertullian and epiphanius for information on the reliability of their evidence for the text. Portrait of a heretic there is little doubt that the teachings of marcion and his followers represented a greater threat to orthodox christianity than any other heresy in the second century. Marcion is a reminder of the results in rejecting the authority and tradition of the church in favor of ones own presuppositions ending with an interpretation and even acceptance of scripture based on those presuppositions. He is an important topic of the early church, the disunity he sparked led to the church defining itself further in. Lieu a comprehensive and authoritative account of the heretic marcion, this volume traces the development of the concept and language of heresy in the setting of an exploration of secondcentury christian intellectual debate.
My position received little support after publication. Marcion, by dermot mcdonald, in the history of christianity, at 104105. On one hand, there was the law given moses, which the apostolic twelve endorsed in matthews gospel. The site includes the gnostic library, with the complete nag hammadi library and a large collection of other primary gnostic scriptures and documents. Tillich states of the gnostics in general, and marcion in particular, that. Pontius pilatus being the governor of judaea, jesus came down to capernaum, a city in galilee, and was. Its reconstructed fragments now appear among the new testament apocrypha. There needed to be a distance between god and matter in marcions thinking, so the creator god of the old testament was not a true god or he was a lesser god. Christian members please remember to read the statement of purpose threads for each forum within christian congregations before posting in the forum.
Aug 05, 2016 marcion is a software forming a study environment of ancient languages esp. Marcion s work known as the antithesis per 1 timothy 6. In any event, this will at least provide the reader a general idea of what marcion s work antithesis may have been like. Marcion was a controversial teacher in the early church. May 11, 2018 marcions church was rigorous, demanding, inspiring, wellorganized, and for about a century fairly successful. The written account of the life of jesus christ, preserved in its original greek by marcion, son of philologus, bishop of sinope. The marcionite bible was not divided into old and new testaments like the modern bible, and was dramatically shorter. Developing some eccentric theological views, he eventually taught that the god of the old testament was not the true god but rather that the true and higher god had been revealed only with jesus c. A version of luke, minus the infancy narrative, was acceptable to marcion since luke was the loyal companion of paul and faithfully handed on pauls words. Marcions teaching was condemned as heresy in the year 144. Although marcion is focused on to study the gnosticism and early christianity, it is an universal library working with various file formats and allowing to collect, organize and backup texts of any kind. Marcionism was an early christian dualist belief system that originated in the teachings of.
He considered himself a follower of paul the apostle, who he believed to have been the only true apostle of. Marcion the study environment of ancient languages coptic, greek, latin. Marcionism is the dualist belief system that originated in rome from the teachings of marcion of sinope around the year 144. What do you get when you cross the marvel universe and a dictionary.
I agree with marcion in that the god of parts of the ot was an entirely different god than the one presented by jesus, but thats about as far as i agree with him. Adolf harnack was a german theologian, scholar and historian. He rejected the old testament and its angry god, seeing a more loving god in the testimonies of jesus and paul. The evidence of marcion s gospel against an assumed marcionite redaction the historical study of early christianity continues to labor under the burden of assumptions carried over from traditional christian here siology. Marcion was the son of a bishop of sinope in pontus. She examines marcion s gospel, apostolikon, and antitheses in detail and compares his principles with those of contemporary christian and nonchristian thinkers, covering a wide range of controversial issues. Marcion came under the influence of the gnostic teacher cedro who believed that the god of the old testament was different from the god and father of the lord jesus christ. For him it was the true account of the history of the jews, but spoke of the demiurge. Ancient critics thought marcion cut out texts he didnt like from an already existing canon, but this is not true. Mar 15, 2017 marcion had bought into platos idea that matter is bad, and so, the god of the old testament, the god who created the world, was not a god that he could stomach. Harnack presents marcion s historical significance. He was not only an extreme literalist, but also an extreme ascetic.